I believe we had this discussion before, so I'll only briefly restate my stance (made up of a few points):
1) I spent $96 a year ago for a chip that can beat a 3GHz P4 according to my own testing. The 3GHz chip still sells for over 2x that price. Point #1, performance vs. value. AMD wins.
2) Heat from AMD CPUs isn't really an issue. It takes a $15 heatsink to cool them. Think AMDs make more heat? The hottest AMD CPU is the just released Opteron x50 model. It has a thermal load of 89W. The hottest Intel CPU is the P4EE 3.4GHz CPU. It has a thermal load of 102.9W. Compare the AMD Athlon XP 2500+ to a 2.4GHz P4. 66W vs 53W. The AMDs just don't run as hot as people think. Heat--no winner (it's pretty close on mainstream chips).
3) You'd have to be talented to bust an AMD chip. About the only way you could break it is by hitting it with something or forcing it to run without a cooling device.
For me, right now, I'm sticking with AMD. You can get a $110 chip to clock 2.5GHz+ on air cooling. Not only that, but if you're worried about heat, you can get a mobile version that runs on less than 50W. A 2600+ mobile chip uses only 45 watts and is the same as the desktop chip, only capable of running its speed at a lower voltage.
Que Everything he just said, expect from me...
I believe we had this discussion before, so I'll only briefly restate my stance (made up of a few points):
1) I spent $96 a year ago for a chip that can beat a 3GHz P4 according to my own testing. The 3GHz chip still sells for over 2x that price. Point #1, performance vs. value. AMD wins.
2) Heat from AMD CPUs isn't really an issue. It takes a $15 heatsink to cool them. Think AMDs make more heat? The hottest AMD CPU is the just released Opteron x50 model. It has a thermal load of 89W. The hottest Intel CPU is the P4EE 3.4GHz CPU. It has a thermal load of 102.9W. Compare the AMD Athlon XP 2500+ to a 2.4GHz P4. 66W vs 53W. The AMDs just don't run as hot as people think. Heat--no winner (it's pretty close on mainstream chips).
3) You'd have to be talented to bust an AMD chip. About the only way you could break it is by hitting it with something or forcing it to run without a cooling device.
For me, right now, I'm sticking with AMD. You can get a $110 chip to clock 2.5GHz+ on air cooling. Not only that, but if you're worried about heat, you can get a mobile version that runs on less than 50W. A 2600+ mobile chip uses only 45 watts and is the same as the desktop chip, only capable of running its speed at a lower voltage.
Thank you, thank you...