seems like you left a few things out. first, i never pk'd or lcked you, and the majority of the time i tried was when you targetted me, and then ran away after i beat you. and after being constantly flamed, and being shoved into ubers with the last thread of health left, you tend to get a little mad and want some revenge. so theres where i take advantage of the "two items every 30 mins" rule. i dont really care about the shield that much, but it would be nice to have back.
also after giving everything back, besides the shield saying "it was a game glitch" doesnt help your credibility too much.