Arguing like this is for private places, not public domain. EVIL_INC and eViL, keep it in PM's and away from the public forums. Nothing against any of you two personally, but you're dropping the amount of relaxed conversations take place here and chewing up perfectly good bandwidth for nothing constructive.
Quite simply, if you carry on the fight, whichever does is banned. Play hard, play nice.
This isn't an invite for you all to comment about how you thought one of the two is or was right. You can comment on my message, however.