Last... there is no definite line between nVidia and ATI for winners and losers.... if Ozzy likes nVidia, he likes nVidia, if you like ATI, .....
The overall point is the fact that the new GPU isn't new at all in this case. The memory sets and the actual chipset for the card is years old.... You can get an older card for $100-$200 and OC it very very very slightly to get that same performance....